Now Available: Writing for Eternity or the Cheese-Stalls

A new monograph on the archivist Carl Friedrich Evers, his 1785 essay on six coins from a burial mound near Grabow, and how his “Wendish” attribution outlived two centuries of scholarship.

Front cover of Writing for Eternity or the Cheese-Stalls: Carl Friedrich Evers and His Essay on 'Wendish' Coins, by Donald S. Yarab

It is my pleasure to announce that Writing for Eternity or the Cheese-Stalls: Carl Friedrich Evers and His Essay on “Wendish” Coins, the first title in the Northcoast Antiquarian Monographs series, is now available in paperback.

The medieval silver coins that numismatists have called Wendenpfennige, Sachsenpfennige, Randpfennige, and cross denarii (denary krzyżowe) have resisted attribution for more than two centuries. One of the first scholars to treat them seriously was Carl Friedrich Evers (1729–1803), archivist to the dukes of Mecklenburg-Schwerin. In 1785 he published a short essay on six small coins recovered from a burial mound near Grabow and attributed them to the Wends, the Slavs of the Elbe lands. That attribution, and in time the names that grew from it, long outlived the arguments against the coins’ association with the Wends as their minting authority.

This monograph tells the story of Evers, his essay, and its reception down to the present: his career in the ducal archive and his correspondence with Johann Bernoulli; the Grabow find and the first reviews; Evers’ return to the coins in his history of Mecklenburg coinage of 1798–1799; Joseph Mader’s critique of 1803–1806; Lisch’s reconsideration of the find in 1845; and the curious afterlife of the “Wendish” label, which the German literature kept while forgetting Evers as its author; the Polish literature, by contrast, seemingly remembered him but seldom read what he wrote. An English translation of the 1785 essay and a transcription of its German text are given in the appendices.

About the title

The title comes from Evers himself. Writing to Bernoulli in October 1785, he complained of reviewers who thought archivists had neither the time nor the inclination to write “for eternity or for the cheese-stalls” (für die Ewigkeit oder Käsebuden), that is, for posterity or for wrapping paper. As it turned out, he wrote for posterity, though not in the way he intended.

Readers who saw my 2023 post on Evers will find here an entirely new and much fuller study.

Paperback, 6 × 9 in., 76pp., US$19.95 postpaid.

Carl Friedrich Evers and the Essay on Coins in a Wendish Burial Mound He Wrote for Posterity

Cover of monograph Carl Friedrich Evers and the Essay He Wrote for Posterity by Donald S. Yarab

Pleased to have completed a translation of Evers’ 1785 essay, which still appears in scholarship today. Although Evers missed the mark in his attribution of the coins to the Wends, he was nonetheless one of the earliest to attempt a scholarly treatment of the coins now known as Randpfennige or cross denarii and certainly amongst the first to illustrate the coins.

A copy of the monograph I prepared to accompany the translation is available with a click of the button below:

Two More Polish Cross Denarii Article Translations for Your Consideration

The articles translated originally were published in Rocznik Kaliski in 2005 and 2010. An author associated with both articles was A. Kędzierski, perhaps the foremost authority on cross denarii in Poland. The articles translated are:

Kędzierski, A., Miłek, S. 2005. Mennica denarów krzyżowych w Kaliszu. Rocznik Kaliski 31, pp. 227-236.

Kędzierski, A. 2010. Czy istnieją denary krzyżowe Władysława Hermana? Rocznik Kaliski 36, pp. 255-262.

Kędzierski’s more recent works, of course, supersede and supplement these articles, but I thought it was still worth translating for better understanding the later works. The articles were translated strictly for use in personal scholarship. The translations can be accessed at the links below.